Skip To Content

How to cut ten thousand words and keep the book

Hugo Brandt, 4 min read

Every second draft I have edited was too long, and every writer knew it before I said so. The trouble is never deciding to cut. It is finding ten thousand words to lose without losing the book.

Cut scenes, not sentences

Trimming a word here and a clause there feels like progress and removes almost nothing. A page of tightened prose is still a page. The cuts that count are whole scenes, and the way to find them is to look at the book from far enough away that you cannot read the sentences.

Open the outline and ask one question of each scene: if this were gone, what would the reader not know by the next chapter? When the honest answer is "nothing", you have found two thousand words.

Keep what you remove

Nothing you cut is lost. It has only stopped being in the way.

Writers hold on to weak scenes because deleting feels final. So do not delete. Move the scene to Cut Scenes in your notebook, where it keeps its history and can come back. In my experience one in ten does, usually shorter and in a different chapter.

Then read it aloud

Once the scenes are gone, read the joins aloud. A cut leaves a seam: a character who knows something they were told in a scene that no longer exists, a morning that follows a morning. Name Check and the Threads view will catch the first kind. Only your ear catches the second.

Ten thousand words is five scenes. You almost certainly have five.

Put it to work on your draft.

Every essay here describes something you can do in Longhand today, and your first book is free.